Showing posts with label Two Cents Worth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Two Cents Worth. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

As we enter 2009, it is no longer imperative the level of GDP growth Malaysia registered in the year that just passed – either 5.5%, 5.0% or even 4.5%. What is more important is the level of economic growth one foresees this year.

Malaysia – Annual GDP Growth (Estimate and Forecast based on official figures)

The official forecast is for a growth of 3.5%. Although we do not disagree that the level of economic activity in 4Q08 – a figure which we will know only by the end of February – may suggest the extent of slowdown going forward, changes in the local and global economic landscape especially in the first six months may affect the projection in both ways.


Malaysia – Quarterly GDP Growth (y-o-y)

As we mentioned last month, many governments have already announced their stimulus packages to manage the impact of the slowdown with the intention to avoid a recession this year, Malaysia included. The question is whether it is only the government that should increase spending.

With Malaysia aiming to be a developed nation by year 2020 with aggressive expansion in the manufacturing sector, the significance of public sector spending is now at low levels. If one analyses contribution of the components of the “three-sector closed economy”, public consumption in Malaysia is relatively insignificant.

By definition, a “three-sector closed economy” comprises public consumption, private consumption and gross fixed capital formation (or investments). By adding net exports (exports less imports), it then becomes a “four-sector open economy”.

Between 2001 and 2007, public consumption or in other words, government spending, constituted only between 14% and 16% of spending of the three sectors. The more significant one has been private sector consumption, representing 55% - 59% of the three sectors, while investments comprised 27% to 31%. (available figures on investments are not divided into that of public and private sectors.)


Malaysia – From the 3-sector “closed economy” perspective (2008 based on Jan-Sept figures)

This observation means that for every 1% reduction in private sector spending, it can only be mitigated by a hefty 4% increase in government consumption to ensure total private and public sector consumptions remain unchanged, assuming status quo on other sectors. But for every 1% reduction in investments, it can be moderated by a 2% increase in public consumption.

For this reason, we see the decision to reduce employees’ contribution to the Employees Provident Fund (EPF) by three percentage points to 8% for two years starting this month as an acceptable policy measure to maintain private sector consumption.

Yes, it may affect employees’ savings for retirement but such a measure is only for two years. If this option is not exercised, more damages may await everyone if the economy succumbs to a prolonged slowdown or recession.



Malaysia – Loans growth, monthly (y-o-y)

This however does not mean that the RM7b stimulus package announced recently is sufficient. While the government’s move, intentionally or otherwise, to reduce public consumption to 13.8% of the three-sector closed economy in the first nine months of 2008 is a good move, the “savings” should now be used to increase its contribution.

In 2000 when the global economies experienced a technical recession, public spending in Malaysia only constituted 12.8% of the three sectors. But this was raised to 14.4% in 2001 with a reduction in contribution from investments but status quo on private spending.

The investments component may also be affected this year in view of the bleak economic outlook that may affect new private direct investments, not to mention possible close down of some existing operations. In addition, loans growth may also be peaking as financial institutions may impose stricter guidelines on new approvals and drawdowns.

We hope the same policy measures to be repeated, i.e. raising public sector contribution to the three-sector closed economy to 14.5% - 15.5% levels this year. This measure is necessary not only to maintain the level of economic activities in the three-sector closed economy but also to overcome any shortfall in net exports, which represented 14.6% of Malaysia’s four-sector open economy last year.

Especially so when the world output is expected to moderate significantly to only 2.2% this year from an estimated 3.7% last year as predicted by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in its latest projections. It expects the US, Euro area and Japan going into recession this year with forecasted GDP contraction of 0.7%, 0.5% and 0.2% respectively.



Which means that Malaysia’s future exports is at stake as these countries represent 35% of its total exports, which dropped 2.6% year-on-year in October 2008. This has not included Malaysia’s other trading partners that may also reduce imports as they are also affected from the global slowdown.

Malaysia – Percentage of Net Exports (2008 based on Jan-Sept figures)

And finally, a reduction in imports in semi-finished products in line with the anticipation for a drop in exports in finished products will also impact manufacturing companies especially those in free trade zones. Any retrenchment exercise arising from this, which we are beginning to hear and read, will then affect private consumption.

So, while consumers will be able to spend more (in aggregate) but wisely following the reduction in EPF contributions, the government will also need to step up its stimulus packages in an effective and efficient manner to weather the current storm.

Stimulus packages can be in various forms, such as important infrastructure projects especially those that were delayed earlier due to high materials costs at that time, agriculture projects that can make us self sufficient on our basic food needs in 5-10 years, developing disbursement of a new fund for selected small and medium scale industries, as well as education grant for retraining retrenched employees.

****
Article Contributed By Ameer Ali Mohamed. Ameer is Director, Financial Research of NextVIEW. He has a total of 20 years experience as a corporate journalist, investment analyst and fund manager, including as research head of two stockbroking firms and CEO/CIO of a funds management company.

Republished with permission.
This article was published in the Just Say It column in Shares Investment (Malaysia edition) January 2009. You can get the latest copy of Shares Investment (Malaysia edition) at leading bookstores in Malaysia.

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Spend Wisely, Please

Stimulus packages here, there and everywhere! They seem to be the order of the day. They are there simply to provide an impetus for growth in a dwindling economy where financial markets cannot.

Interestingly, these current efforts are not taken by individual countries, but rather en bloc. For example, at the recently concluded Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (Apec) summit, the member economies agreed to coordinate their stimulus packages to avert a global recession.

Late last month, the European Union (EU) launched a Euro 200b financial package, equivalent to 1.5% of the 27-nation union's gross domestic product (GDP). Of this amount, 85 per cent will come from national government budgets with the remainder coming from the EU and the European Investment Bank's budgets.

Thus far, the United States had announced a package totalling US$1.5 trillion. Observers do not discount this ballooning to US$2.0b as economists are expecting an additional US$500b tax cut plan soon. The latest was a second stimulus package worth US$800b of two parts – US$600b to buy mortgage related debt and securities; and US$200b to buy consumer debt securities.

These do not include the possibility of President-elect Barack Obama considering a circa US$1.1 trillion economic stimulus package as soon as he takes office on Jan 20 in a bid to create or save 2.5 million jobs.

Other stimulus packages include Britain's £20 billion (slightly more than 1% of its GDP) and China's 4 trillion yuan over the next two years with emphasis on public welfare projects, infrastructure, environment protection and post quake reconstruction in south-western China.


IS RM7B FOR MALAYSIA ENOUGH?

In Malaysia, a RM7b stimulus package was announced, to be spent on “high impact” projects. The funds would come from savings due to lower than expected subsidies on retail fuel prices following battered global crude oil prices. It remains to be seen if this is sufficient to withstand the current onslaught of the global economic crisis.

What is certain is that the package appears minute, considering it is only 0.93% of Malaysia’s annualised GDP, at current prices of RM751b based on figures for the first three quarters of 2008.

Some may argue that the funds are complemented by the three-percentage-point reduction in the employees' contribution to the Employees Provident Fund, which could release RM4.8b per annum to private consumption if all employees opt for it. However, dwindling exports and net outflow of portfolio and overseas investments are points of concern.

Malaysia’s exports are already affected as its major trading partners – such as the United States, Europe, Japan and Singapore – have either gone into technical recession or are experiencing acute slowdown. Net real exports of goods and services dropped 14.8% in 3Q08, down from 20.0% growth in the previous quarter – a major factor that pulled down the 3Q08 GDP to 4.7% from a revised 6.7% in 2Q08.

Portfolio investment outflow rose to RM38.4b in 3Q08 from RM31.0b in 2Q08, due to the continued global de-leveraging process. Additionally, there was a RM16.1b outflow in 3Q08 for overseas investments by Malaysian companies against an inflow of RM3.6b in the previous quarter.

Hence, we expect additional stimulus to be introduced early next year.


BETWEEN STIMULUS, RESCUE AND BAILOUT

Certainly, the world's governments will have to face cynical comments from their respective opposition political parties and even the people who voted for them. Their cynicism may include their usage positive-sounding words like “stimulus package” to mask what is essentially a “bailout” of financial giants.

Political differences aside, one of the main reasons the leaders must use positive words, from an economic perspective, is to avoid extreme worry among consumers as this would aggravate the already subdued economic situation.

The value of national income is computed from the sum of private investments, public consumption and investments, and exports, minus imports. It would be a disaster if all the elements of investment, consumption and exports contract. So, it all boils down to managing confidence.

While growth in consumer spending, private investments and exports are moving into negative territory, one way to cushion the fall in national income is to increase government spending, with a view that over time, this will mend private sector sentiment.

Granted, stimulus packages must be spent wisely and channeled to sectors that are deemed to have a “higher economic multiplier”. As EU Monetary Affairs commissioner Joaquin Almunia puts it: “If the impulse is not coordinated, one plus one might not equal two, but less, even zero. If it is coordinated, one plus one may equal three.”

If a stimulus package is geared to rescue sinking financial giants, it must be done carefully – to rescue, not to bailout – for two main reasons, namely to rescue the financial sector (an important component of the economy) and to save the employees.

It is a “bailout” if, in the process, the current major or controlling shareholder(s) and top executives of the financial giants are protected while the employees, who have no say in the running of the institution, get retrenched. Giant institutions falter due to the doing or oversight of the top executives and, to a certain extent, the chairman and board members. Hence, they should be replaced if government monies are used to finance the rescue. Otherwise, the same mistakes may be repeated once the economic cycle comes back in the future.

Independent non-executive directors should also be seen to act in the interests of minority shareholders, and not for the benefit of controlling shareholders. It is high time indeed for corporate journalists, in their coverage of listed companies, to also quote independent non-executive directors to make them answerable to minority shareholders and employees.

****
Article Contributed By Ameer Ali Mohamed. Ameer is Director, Financial Research of NextVIEW. He has a total of 20 years experience as a corporate journalist, investment analyst and fund manager, including as research head of two stockbroking firms and CEO/CIO of a funds management company.

Republished with permission.
This article was published in the Just Say It column in Shares Investment (Malaysia edition) December 2008. You can get the latest copy of Shares Investment (Malaysia edition) at leading bookstores in Malaysia.

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

We have seen many things happen this year and records being broken in the financial markets like many records being broken in 2008 Olympics in China. The year 2008 would not be forgotten by many, especially those who are investing in the financial markets. It is one of the most volatile years in the financial markets since year 2000, or perhaps in history.

Let us review what happened this year and try to forecast what is likely going to happen next year. After all, forecasting is always based on historical information and forecasts are not 100% accurate all the time. However, it helps us to prepare expected challenges in the future. There is a very good Malay proverb for investors in the financial markets and that is “Sediakan payung sebelum hujan” and it means get an umbrella ready before the rain.


Average Weekly Range % (Volatility) of KLCI since 1994

In Malaysia, the year started with a very bullish sentiment accumulated from a six years bullish trend that started in year 2002 after the dotcom bubble burst in the year 2000. The Kuala Lumpur Composite Index was at about 600 points. The momentum starts to get very bullish in the mid year 2006, when the KLCI was at about 900 points and one year later, it created a new record high. On April 2007, I wrote in Smart Investor and forecasted the KLCI to go as high as 1,500 points. In January 2008, the KLCI closed the highest level ever at 1,516.22 points.

While the equity markets were making new highs, a crisis was already brewing in the United States. During the year 2006-2007, nearly 1.3 million U.S. housing properties were subject to foreclosure activity, up 79% from 2006 because of interest rates has increased and prices of properties did not go up as expected. Prior to that, easy and low interest credit was available to people who are not credit-worthy. Therefore a sub-prime mortgage crisis began that eventually lead to bigger financial crisis.

Equity markets around the world soon realized the extent of damage sub-prime crisis can create and started to correct downwards in October 2007. Historical high closes were created on major indices around the world. The US Dow Jones Industrial Average was at 14,164 points, London’s FTSE was at 6,730 points, Hong Kong’s Hang Seng index was at 31,638 points and our close neighbor Singapore was at 3,875 points. These markets started to correct downwards after October 2007 but the Malaysian equity market continues to climb. Only property and construction companies were affected in 2007 from June onwards as the crisis at that time was only on properties.

The first quarter

In October the KLCI was at about 1,400 points and it climbed to its peak of 1,516 points in January 2008 and while other markets fell. This was primarily due to the increasing price of Malaysia’s major commodity, the crude palm oil. In early 2007, the price of crude palm oil was at about RM1,900 per metric ton and about 1 year later, it shot up more than double to a historical high of RM4,300 in March. Major plantation companies which are heavyweights in the KLCI enjoyed huge increases. In early 2007, SIME Berhad price was at RM7.00 and rose 85% to RM13.00 in January 2008. Another heavyweight IOI Corporation Berhad’s share price rose 140% from about RM3.50 to RM8.50.

In January 2008 after the KLCI made the historical high and which my earlier forecast target met, I made a forecast on Smart Investor (published in February 2008) that the KLCI is going to go into a major correction with a 1,100 target, after analyzing the current economic conditions and the price chart. The price of crude palm oil was trading at around RM3,500 per metric ton for about 4 months after correcting from the historical high in March. This has led to a decline in share prices of plantation companies.

UK’s leading financial house Northern Rock faced financial difficulties in 2007 and in February 2008, it was nationalized (being bought over by the government. Another financial giant was facing difficulties in the US. Bear Sterns was acquired by J.P. Morgan Chase and the government though the central bank has to provide a loan of US$29 billion for the deal to go through. It was uncertain times for Malaysians as they were going to a general election in March. It created another history in Malaysian politics when the ruling government failed to get 2/3 majority for the first time. The KLCI plunged further in face of uncertainty. All these happened in the first quarter of the year.

The second quarter

In the second quarter of the year, the financial crisis deepens. The IMF warned that America's mortgage crisis has spiraled into "the largest financial shock since the Great Depression" and there is now a one-in-four chance of a full-blown global recession over the next twelve months. A report from Bloomberg on the 19th of May 2008 revealed that US$379 billion vanished in asset write-downs and credit losses since the beginning of 2007, including reserves set aside for bad loans, at more than 100 of the world's biggest banks and securities firms. The IMF added that world's financial firms could end up shouldering US$1 trillion worth of losses from the credit crunch.

The price of crude oil suddenly started to increase sharply in April. The price of crude oil rose 40% from US$100 per barrel in early April to a historical high of US$140 in June. Malaysians were in a shock when the government, for the first time in history increased consumer petrol price by 45% from RM1.92 per litre to RM2.70 per litre in June. The increase has caused price of consumer goods to increase and this eventually led to higher inflation. The KLCI was trading in a range of 1,200 points to 1,300 points in the second quarter.

Events in the second quarter fueled the already worsening crisis. With rising inflation and the pressure from governments to lower interest rates to support the financial system, it has created an economic problem. The pain from the deepening crisis is felt in the third quarter.

The third quarter

More government bailouts are happening in the west, and these bailouts caused tax payers money. Equity markets continue to decline from July to September and sentiments continue to be bearish and a new fear has arisen, recession. Most equity markets have already gone down by at least 40% in September since October 2007 peak.

Most of the major events happen in the last month of the third quarter, which is in September. Financial giant Merrill Lynch was acquired by Bank of America for $50 billion. Another financial giant, Lehman Brothers declared bankruptcy on 15 September 2008, facing a refusal by the federal government to bail it out. The US Federal Reserve provided an emergency loan of $85 billion to America’s largest insurance company AIG. Just over three weeks later the Fed reported that AIG had drawn down $70.3 billion of that $85 billion facility. These were only some of the highlights and I believe more financial institutions were facing serious problems. The financial catastrophe has not yet landed in Asia including Malaysia.

The recession fears and financial turmoil have caused price of commodities to fall. Price of light sweet crude oil fell to US$100 per barrel in September. Price of crude palm oil fell to RM2,100 per metric ton, more than half from the peak in March. The sharp decline in prices of commodities was not able to lower the prices of consumer goods and therefore, inflation remains high. Malaysia's inflation rate jumped to a 26-year high of 8.5 percent in August. It only managed to ease to 8.2% in September. The government decided to review price of fuel on a monthly basis and remove some subsidy. The KLCI was at 1,000 points in September 2008. The bearish sentiments have caused me to change my bearish forecast target from 1,100 points to 850 to 900 points.


Weekly relative performance chart of KLCI, Crude Palm Oil and Crude Oil since January 2007

The Fourth quarter

Markets continue decline as more negative corporate earnings were reported and this time more aggressively. Many markets have suspended trading in this quarter because of a breach in the trading range limit. Some markets fell to its sharpest ever fall in a single day. The Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJI) made its biggest single day fall ever with 777.68 points or 7% in the end of September after the US$700 billion bailout plan by the US government failed to get support initially.

Further financial packages from governments and reduction in key interest rates have eased the aggressive decline and markets have found a bottom in late October. The US has cut its interest rates to near zero. The KLCI closed as low as 829.41 in October and is currently at 867.35 points, as at 7 November 2008.

Prices of commodities continue to decline heavily. Price of Crude Oil is currently trading at US$35 per barrel. Just 2 quarters ago, the price of crude oil was at US$140.

The table on the left shows performances of major indices since January 2008:

Most of the indices started to decline after October 2007 last year and if calculated from that peak, most of the indices have fallen more than 50%. Malaysia equity market generally fell about 36%.

Where do we go from here?

In my previous article in Smart Investor, I mentioned that the KLCI is heading for 850 to 900 range level for support. The KLCI has found a support at 800 points. Has the market bottomed out?
In my humble opinion, temporarily yes, at least until the end of the year.

The equity market normally leads the economy by 8 to 12 months. The equity market has already fallen about 36% from the January high. The Malaysian economy is currently slowing down little, unlike other countries especially the west which is slowing rapidly. Our neighbour Singapore is already in a technical recession. Just recently, DBS Bank, a major bank in Singapore planned to cut its workforce by 6% or 900 jobs as profits declined sharply. Companies in Singapore are already preparing for an economic slowdown and economist are predicting that the worst is still far away from what is happening now. I'd expect Malaysia to cut interest rates in 2009 to spur the economy.

I expect the Malaysian economy into recession next year if the financial markets do not recover fast and when this happens, another sell down is expected in the equity market before the market finds its bottom. In 1997, the KLCI fell about 80% from the high of 1,300 points to a low of 260 points. Just a thought, if the current crisis is more severe than the Asian financial crisis, do you think it can fall more than 80% from the high of 1,500 points? My forecast is between 500 to 550 points.

The year 2009 may be a year of uncertainty with a bearish bias and the equity market volatility is expected to settle down a little from the 2008 tsunami. Investors should stay alert in 2009 as short term opportunities may still arise. Investors should learn how to identify these stocks fundamentally and technically. Investors should also look at other investment alternatives like the futures market, which allows investors to also profit from bear markets so that if the year 2009 remains bearish, the investment portfolio can still grow.

While others whine and complain on their disastrous investments in the past years, smart investors learn from their past investments and seek more knowledge to improve their investing skills. Investment education is the best investment when markets are uncertain and bearish. The experience and knowledge learned will prepare you as a better investor in the future.

I wish you a Happy New Year 2009 and may your investments continue to grow in this New Year.

***
The article above was published in Smart Investor December 2008 issue and is modified with current information. Article contributed by Private Trader, Market Expert, Trading Coach and Chief Market Strategist of Nextview, Mr. Benny Lee. For more articles and commentaries from Benny, click HERE.

Upcoming Workshop from Benny Lee:
Market Outlook and how to Pick Right Value Stocks by Benny Lee | 3 Jan 2009 (K. Lumpur). Click on the title for more details.

Wednesday, November 5, 2008

Malaysia is not going into recession next year... economy fundamentals are strong, says our up and coming PM. But what is happening now, Mr. PM to be cum Finance Minister, does not seem to look like it...

RM$5b "bailout" loan to State investment company, ValueCap Sdn Bhd from EPF to invest in the stock market. ValueCap owes its three shareholders RM$5.1b. The move was highly questionable. Deputy PM, now Finance Minister defended the move by saying that ValueCap has good performance record. Then why the hell do they need the RM5b loan if the they performed well.

Goverment spending RM$42b in September to defend the Ringgit... Wow. Again Mr. PM to be, why do we need to spend so much to defend our Ringgit if the economy is fundamentally strong? Haven't we learned something from the Asian Financial crisis? Oh.. I forgot, your right hand man (Finance Minister II) is a gambler and he once lost big during the Asian financial crisis. Like all gamblers, revenge would be sweet... our sour. I just hope we would need to get assistance from World's loan shark, the IMF in the near future.

And recently RM7b stimulus package to strengthen the economy and boost confidence within the private sector. I am OK with this, but I always fear the implemention part and our government has very good track records for this.. remember all the development corridors? from south, north, east, west , heaven and earth... what happened to them? I am sure money will be syphoned out of the package. YAB PM to be.... tak cukup lah (not enough).

Our current PM says price of goods MUST fall, now that price of oil has declined... but who is listening Mr. PM? Last time I checked, prices still the same. In fact, some vendors still has the gut to raise prices even now...Inflation to come down? Domestic Trade and Affairs minister said that there is no guarantee that price of goods must come down.

Bahhhh... But I must salute him for changing his finance minister portfolio with his deputy because he knows that he do not know anything about finance and economy. I am not sure whether the deputy knows about the economy or not but I only know his brother is a great banker.

Can Malaysia depend on Finance Minister II?.... He's a gambler. What if Malaysian currency continues to depreciate? Gamble more? His hands must be itchy after 11 years.

No wonder the opposition walked out of parliament in protest.

***
Article contributed by Private Trader, Market Expert, Trading Coach and Chief Market Strategist of Nextview, Mr. Benny Lee. For more articles and commentaries from Benny, click HERE.